SAP SQL Anywhere

Question

I'm doing some tests with the new v17 PIVOT clause, based on the according samples in the demo database.

The samples show some methods to specify an IN list with a fixed list of constants, such as

    SUM( Salary ) TotalSalary  
    FOR DepartmentID IN ( 100, 200, 300, 400, 500 )

However, how can I use a dynamic list here?

The docs seem to imply that I can only use a constant-expression as the IN list - for all other possibilities, such as "IN variablename", "IN (subquery)", "IN (ALL)", "IN (ANY)", it states

"Specify the XML keyword when using this form of the IN clause."

whereas I do want to generate a regular SQL result set and not with one with XML columns.

(Aside: And the docs seem to be precise here, i.e. using "IN (ALL)" leads to a syntax error when used without PIVOT XML:

SELECT * 
FROM ( SELECT DepartmentID, State, Salary 
       FROM   Employees
       WHERE State IN ( 'OR', 'CA', 'AZ', 'UT' )
     ) MyPivotSourceData
   PIVOT ( 
      SUM( Salary) TotalSalary  
      FOR State IN (ALL)
   ) PivotedData
ORDER BY DepartmentID

returns SQLCODE -131 for "ALL".)

So say, I would want to generate a separate column for each existing DepartmentID and not restrict that to already known values, do I need to use dynamic SQL with EXECUTE IMMEDIATE (with its disadvantages like extra masking of string literals) or is there a better alternative?

Accepted Answer

Ah, the IN variablename syntax seems to work for non-XML result sets, too (unless otherwise specified in the cited docs, methinks):

Here I'm using an array type and order the array by using ARRAY_AGG with a fitting ORDER BY (and no, I'm not yet using array types regularly...):

CREATE VARIABLE @varDepartments INT ARRAY;
SET @varDepartments =
   (SELECT ARRAY_AGG(DISTINCT DepartmentID ORDER BY DepartmentID) FROM Employees);
SELECT * 
FROM ( SELECT DepartmentID, State, Salary 
       FROM   Employees
       WHERE State IN ( 'OR', 'CA', 'AZ', 'UT' )
     ) MyPivotSourceData
   PIVOT ( 
      SUM( Salary ) TotalSalary  
      FOR DepartmentID IN @varDepartments
   ) MyPivotedData
ORDER BY State;

In contrast, all attempts with an "In (subquery)" have failed so far.

Answer 2

You can use a variable in the IN clause. This is described in the documentation

For example, here is a block of code that pivots the accumulated property history information (new in V17):

begin
  create or replace variable @props varchar(120) array;
  select *
    into #propdata
    from sp_property_history();
  set @props = ( select array_agg( distinct name order by name ) from #propdata );
  select *
    from ( select name, ticks, time_recorded, time_delta, value_delta from #propdata ) mysourcedata
   pivot ( sum( value_delta ) delta for name in @props ) mydata
   order by ticks desc;
end;

Notice how the list of properties is first stored in the @props variable (as an array) and then that variable is used in the PIVOT clause.

HTH

SAP SQL Anywhere

How can I specify the IN list for a PIVOT clause dynamically?

Follow this question

Related questions